First, the crew breaks down the weekend’s big talking points coming out of Elimination Chamber, including match reactions, what’s clicking (and what isn’t) on the road to WrestleMania, and how quickly the conversation shifts when a certain very-evil, very-nice wildcard shows up. Danhausen’s debut sparks debate about crowd reactions vs. internet reactions, plus what WWE can do with him now that he’s officially in the mix. 

From there, the show bounces through the wider wrestling world: AEW chatter (including the crew’s love of social-media moments and crowd chants), AAA’s Rey de Reyes sword lore, and plenty of classic Mayhem tangents—including the important hard-hitting question of the week: what is the most hardcore ice cream? 

Then Referee George Ross takes us inside his recent weekends in the trenches, including a deep dive into the world of CZW—from the 27th anniversary weekend and ultraviolence chaos, to why the company’s venue/schedule momentum feels genuinely exciting again (including the brewery “black light” shows). 

The episode closes with a full “What We Learned” round—covering Danhausen-related life lessons, why you shouldn’t judge a two-minute moment before the follow-up, and Sorg’s backstage notes from New Japan Pro Wrestling work (yes, including the “New Japan is a slumber party” theory). 

In Team Warr: Allison & KC Warr, celebrating nine years (and their first-date-iversary is today) and proudly proving that yes, Tinder can work.

In Team Bearcat: Karielle & Keith Haught, together for over a decade, married for two years, and bonded through pro wrestling (and a first date at Steak ’n Shake).

The rules are simple: answer in secret, guess your partner’s answer, and try not to start a “hard conversation” on the drive home. The questions? Wrestling-coded, slightly unhinged, and frequently… whoopee-adjacent.

This week, the crew talks:
• John Cena’s Boston Intercontinental Title moment and what’s next for Dom Mysterio
• AEW Blood & Guts chaos and Hangman vs Powerhouse Hobbs
• NXT’s Thea Hale & Joe Hendry comedy gold
• The most unbelievable 24/7 Title reigns ever (crowns, planes, and pregnancies!)
• VCW Victory Rumble recap and Pittsburgh indie updates
• Imagining a Carnegie Museum wrestling event with Beastman in the dino room
• “What We Learned” this week in wrestling

Find more episodes and links at www.WrestlingMayhemShow.com

This week we dive into NXT’s Halloween Havoc and all its chaos — Jeff Hardy’s tribute to Bray Wyatt, Trick Williams’ big moment, and an unexpected AAA crossover.
We also talk Braun Strowman’s new Everything on the Menu series, revisit the WELC match between El Torito and Hornswoggle, and speculate on a Vince Russo JCW run.

What We Learned:

Viral promos need better payoffs

Tatum Paxley finally shines

Jelly Roll’s inspiring story with Triple H

Happy anniversary to WWE 2K20’s infamous bugs

🎧 Subscribe for weekly wrestling talk at WrestlingMayhemShow.com

Plus: puppet puns, wrestling merch mania, and hilarious tangents with Sorg, Rizz, and Mad Mike.

🎙 Subscribe & join the mayhem at WrestlingMayhemShow.com

WrestlingPodcast #TripleMania #RonHunt #WWE #IndependentWrestling #PuppetWrestling #WMS970 #RWA #2PW

CM Punk's return to WWE:

His return promo was lackluster and disappointing, not like his original return promo in Chicago

There is debate around whether he's genuinely excited to be back or just there for the money

He could play a hypocritical heel character that gets called out

AEW Dynamite show in Pittsburgh:

Tournament format has been fun and entertaining

Lots of hometown wrestlers got spots and pops from the crowd (The Mane Event, Lee Moriarty, Lady Frost)

Explanation that injuries/illness changed up some planned matches

Learning about Marco Narciso

The improv nature of wrestling

His coaches at 880 Wrestling have been amazing teachers

Honey Darling's horror movie podcast "Queens of NC 17":

Reviews lesser known, crappy horror films and makes fun of them

Very raw, unedited show with no outline, lots of tangents and personal stories

Also does "Queens of Reality TV" podcast reviewing bad reality shows

Rhea Ripley's autographed paper selling for $580 in WWE auction:

Sold for way more than Xavier Woods' and Kofi Kingston's autographs

She wrote "Mommy's moisture" on it and licked the paper before signing

Check out the Indy Wrestling US Network at www.indywrestling.network. For a short time, get a 7-day FREE trial to access a growing collection of content.

**A special shout out to our Manager Level Patreon supporter Bradley Ruthers (@HeelBradley)

Join us LIVE at 10 PM ET (after WWE NXT) on Facebook, Youtube, and Twitch!

You can support the show at Patreon.com/wrestlingmayhemshow! Go to wrestlingmayhemshow.com for more entertainment!

Thanks to Basick Sickness (@basicksickness) for the awesome intro for the show

wrestlingpodcast #wrestlingmayhemshow #cmpunk #wwe #aew #madmike #ronniestarks #sorgatron #sorgatronmedia #honeydarling #marconarcisso #horrormovies #comedy #pittsburgh #independentwrestling

Is CM Punk genuinely excited to be back in WWE, or is he just there for the money?
Why was AEW's show in Pittsburgh changed up compared to what was originally planned?
What is the premise of Honey Darling's podcast "Queens of NC 17"?
How much did Rhea Ripley's autographed paper sell for at the WWE auction?
What has Marco Narciso learned about wrestling?
What has Honey Darling learned from getting involved in Pittsburgh's indie wrestling scene?